The book over all is an A+. It has far more pages than I would have guessed and it is high quality with many pictures from the movies. It also has movie trivia. The garments go into great detail - I printed 8 pages for each of the things I planned to make and put in my peechee - the owl post pullover and the expect patronus mittens. While the Beauxbatons Academy of Magic blue caplet is lovely, I wouldn't have anywhere to wear that and can't think of an event for it. The chamber of secrets beanie is also an awesome looking beanie. It's a no frills easy to knit beany - level beginner but looks fantastic. I don't like the super fine #1 weight yarns they are using on several projects Including Hermoine's timeturner sweater, and have to change the pattern for the Expecto Patronus mittens because I refuse to do them in 1 weight yarn. Most of the projects were DK 3 Weight, but the owl post sweater uses worsted medium 4 weight as does the Weasley sweater.The project that is most lacking in this book is professor Umbridge's cat scarf which was really awful. All of the other projects including the dish cloths - which struck me as filler, did look very well designed.It's a beautiful coffee table book. The sweater patterns do look solid and there are some lovely objects that are obviously inspired by the movie.